{ "at": "2026-09-15T10:09:51.576070+00:00", "status": "accepted-by-agent", "scope": "Same goPure Targ adaptation; disclosed musical gates only; no film/owner approval", "candidate": { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v02/gopure-targ-uk-master.wav", "sha256": "aec6bcd423f6b65a66ccf53af1a2ea6377a7b150cd2142d64b819622947296ae" }, "adjudications": [ { "claim": "Raw refine02 A sings initial-stress ме́не.", "disposition": "accepted-observation", "reason": "Local A/B/source review confirmed this real defect; director-edit-v01 used same-run B correct мене́ in one 1.17s window. Actual corrected sound reviewed; all other PCM samples identical.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/mene-stress-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "8c4b37e1ce95d53a18ec9f5f74edfbe45639b4255c6ff9c367bddb1e85fbfba2" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repair-mene-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "015428f1b32a5ac5c9ca111ce5562a6c8d95e831ddf1331ab6ca521b9a58a46b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v02/provenance.json", "sha256": "e7761b32ba5f2ac56b9ec7dbbc1b0dcc1980e426a9168a2d111a75bf86febfd3" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Predicative шко́да in corrected hook must instead be шкода́.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Context means жаль, for which both stresses are attested; published linguistic analysis and pinned dictionary corroborate the prepared root-stress choice. Unlike мене, this is not a defect.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repair-mene-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "015428f1b32a5ac5c9ca111ce5562a6c8d95e831ddf1331ab6ca521b9a58a46b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/preparation/shkoda-stress-primary-20260915.json", "sha256": "5f5c05895a80315d426bcd26d852acc18cb66b96c4fc0b7a5c037b100d391b7e" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/stress-ledger-v04.json", "sha256": "99e48a8c8e73ed4f5da9a2feb1f919c98e3a6dcb32e5b8a0936bba0062b028db" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Small excerpt begins with an extra А or truncates ми з Андрієм; therefore local comp changed neighboring words.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Excerpt starts on the existing tail of колишнього and ends during backstory. All PCM outside6.04–7.21s is bit-identical to v01. Full body1 establishes neighboring words.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repair-mene-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "015428f1b32a5ac5c9ca111ce5562a6c8d95e831ddf1331ab6ca521b9a58a46b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body1-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "2b543141677865a81a8e71d475503a5741d172dd60a2f7a0db2f8360268206c4" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v02/provenance.json", "sha256": "e7761b32ba5f2ac56b9ec7dbbc1b0dcc1980e426a9168a2d111a75bf86febfd3" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Source and candidate coverage can be inferred from supplied timestamps.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Full input byte coverage is reproducible; attention cannot be inferred from labels. final-form-v02 mislocates store at~100s and source Stop; all its numeric local locators are discarded. Use local ASR clock and actual segmented comparisons; whole judgment is qualitative only.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "a77dcf7d84230b68cb4b8367c7ebc92c885563700f3cec0c4130b589ecc5778d" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/diagnostics-v01/alignment-refine02-take1-draft-v01.json", "sha256": "db8bb9cc9b44431324b257842b2f571772986fb8ffcfb4203e6e6c40b9621908" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "New candidate sings «Не муч шкіру всім підряд» and adapts melasma.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "That line is absent from actual v02 local review and submitted text. Actual advice is «Стій. Не все підряд. Доглядай щодня». Defined target problem is neck bands/creases, not a new melasma problem. Whole reviewer leaked historical/source concepts.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "a77dcf7d84230b68cb4b8367c7ebc92c885563700f3cec0c4130b589ecc5778d" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body3-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "dcf3bce266d872246556da507b22864a0e7bc51f6f212e1d29c6984f7d766d8f" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-care-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3e1b3d841f8f23b776aa55c8725301eb3cbb9f708859f899f2942a957ab24e59" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/problem-passport-v01.json", "sha256": "962fcb6ce7bbca163db364c5748b09f304cd8d2788bd006a5b49b6298703852f" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Both codas are spoken; first source Stop is zero signal; held six is two seconds of empty silence; baseline lacks її/свою.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Owner gap adjudication and actual local comparisons establish both sung codas and existing baseline her/own meaning. Decay, holds and rhetorical release must not be relabeled silence. No edits were made to repair these invented faults.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-music-gap-b614aa3b3e-20260915/owner-feedback-v01.json", "sha256": "ddb3fce06e5fc60cf2d0596b73b6c94430b2cdc5700f38f8589e6ddb2ff6a358" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body3-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "dcf3bce266d872246556da507b22864a0e7bc51f6f212e1d29c6984f7d766d8f" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body5-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "b41f1eda97301a4b0cc12292a1e7ab125886368a30ffee3231bac9440edeaad5" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "New brand descriptor is мікрокрем or нічний крем, and form instruction may omit words.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Narrow blind reviews disagreed. Broader high-bitrate final coda explicitly distinguishes [mij krɛm] from extra micro/night phonemes, confirms entire name/phone/form instruction and conditions. Independent ASR recognizes мій and surrounding full sequence. The й is brief; that coarticulation remains disclosed, not invented extra syllables.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/takes/take_refine02_1.asr.json", "sha256": "a264e5f521edcf82fb2d8da1df2e791e3f709749d8fd63e8fcd9a3cc6d7b4c3a" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/refine02-1-ending-blind-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1ebe3a19bbbfda5f66fc6a0626319ec5a4b2f5e38cb5676344d48aaaf5e7eb7c" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Coda has exactly2.5s of instrumental tail.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Actual decoded master is203.240998s; ASR estimates final word release around202.4s. Review numeric tail is not adopted. Complete word and musical decay are supported; no universal tail duration is imposed.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v02/provenance.json", "sha256": "e7761b32ba5f2ac56b9ec7dbbc1b0dcc1980e426a9168a2d111a75bf86febfd3" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/diagnostics-v01/alignment-refine02-take1-draft-v01.json", "sha256": "db8bb9cc9b44431324b257842b2f571772986fb8ffcfb4203e6e6c40b9621908" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Care excerpt ends the song at piano; baseline contains no enacted care.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Piano is merely that excerpt boundary, followed by second gaze and personal close in full audio. Baseline already has enacted care/ingredients; new gains are explicit donor, phrase separation and neck-specific behavioral payoff, not invention of all care meaning.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-care-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3e1b3d841f8f23b776aa55c8725301eb3cbb9f708859f899f2942a957ab24e59" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body5-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "b41f1eda97301a4b0cc12292a1e7ab125886368a30ffee3231bac9440edeaad5" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Longer segment, 100% stress statement, perfect pitch, matching duration or model praise prove a perfect song.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Duration and filled fields are not artistic evidence. Scoped word checking and concrete gestures support agent acceptance only; exact instrumental identifications, invented timings, flawless-pitch/same-person claims and blanket superiority are excluded.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body5-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "b41f1eda97301a4b0cc12292a1e7ab125886368a30ffee3231bac9440edeaad5" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-form-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1189705ebb6e670ab84e0cc38c2b184d3feae017dbfe467d78f7fe504ece4069" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "a77dcf7d84230b68cb4b8367c7ebc92c885563700f3cec0c4130b589ecc5778d" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Source-linked rhetorical behavior improved over baseline.", "disposition": "accepted-observation", "reason": "Repeated слід endings retain an audible cell across escalating causes; first negation opens pity, second gaze repeats and reverses it; Stop is a distinct reply; explicit donor and exposed-neck payoff fix causal ambiguity. Local ABCs and whole development corroborate these gains without requiring softer singing.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body1-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "2b543141677865a81a8e71d475503a5741d172dd60a2f7a0db2f8360268206c4" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body2-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "f23a6f3afee0524971becb375932494bf9287cb5318b7a6146034005ca705874" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body3-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "dcf3bce266d872246556da507b22864a0e7bc51f6f212e1d29c6984f7d766d8f" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/abc-body5-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "b41f1eda97301a4b0cc12292a1e7ab125886368a30ffee3231bac9440edeaad5" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-care-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3e1b3d841f8f23b776aa55c8725301eb3cbb9f708859f899f2942a957ab24e59" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-form-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1189705ebb6e670ab84e0cc38c2b184d3feae017dbfe467d78f7fe504ece4069" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Source correspondence is now identical in every dimension.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "English still has more elastic conversational attacks/short aside endings and less local-offer density. New performance retains some broad sustained resolutions. One generated singer voices all roles; rhetorical differentiation is heard, not actual distinct people.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-form-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1189705ebb6e670ab84e0cc38c2b184d3feae017dbfe467d78f7fe504ece4069" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "a77dcf7d84230b68cb4b8367c7ebc92c885563700f3cec0c4130b589ecc5778d" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-care-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3e1b3d841f8f23b776aa55c8725301eb3cbb9f708859f899f2942a957ab24e59" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Every fullmix word boundary is measured exactly.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Words are independently ASR-located or explicitly interpolated inside uncertain spans. Listening checks lexical presence/stress; it does not convert ASR estimates into phoneme measurements. First consonant and complete end have listening support, not sample-precise phoneme labels.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/diagnostics-v01/alignment-refine02-take1-draft-v01.json", "sha256": "db8bb9cc9b44431324b257842b2f571772986fb8ffcfb4203e6e6c40b9621908" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "a77dcf7d84230b68cb4b8367c7ebc92c885563700f3cec0c4130b589ecc5778d" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-coda-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "62ba6832107f3e91ccaad16fc44d1768b09c7e02d559d3fa98c0d5c8cb20dd58" } ], "blocking": false } ], "decision": "Accept locally corrected refine02 A as musical master: new source-linked rhetoric and intact reviewed words/brand/offer justify improvement over the existing baseline. No score is assigned.", "limitations": [ "All listening is model-mediated; no claim of continuous human listening or owner approval.", "Full originals and candidate supplied as complete48kmono tracks for form; high-bitrate stereo local clips cover all sung sections. Reviewer mistakes and clock uncertainty are retained.", "English retains more elastic short speech gestures; target care/offer remains denser and some endings more sustained.", "Brief coarticulation of й in the form instruction; local contextual review and ASR support it, but no phoneme alignment precision is claimed.", "Three/six-week result and complete smooth neck belong to the same fictional dramatization, not guaranteed efficacy. Future film must display the product context and reverify actual visual resolution/identity/fades.", "Four review outcomes had no usable response and were not retried: b-ingredients-blind-v02, candidate-v01-critical, abc-body4-v01, abc-body6-v01. Both music jobs are known SUCCESS." ], "unresolvedBlocking": [] }